Take a look at the episodes that our listeners can’t get enough of! Based on download statistics, these fan favorites capture the nostalgia, stories, and unforgettable moments that define The 90s Rewind Report. (Updated Monthly - Last Updated: 12/07/2025)
1. S02E16: Halloween Film Franchise Multiverse Explained
Michael Reagan and Nate Lane take a stab at unraveling one of horror’s most confusing—but fascinating—franchises: Halloween. From the 1978 original that redefined slasher cinema to the endless reboots, sequels, and multiverse timelines that followed, the guys break down how Halloween splintered into multiple realities.
They explore the three (or four, depending who you ask) major timelines, the Rob Zombie reimagining that divided fans, and Halloween III: Season of the Witch—the bizarre standalone entry that ditched Michael Myers altogether in favor of killer masks and cult conspiracies. We’re sorting out Halloween’s tangled timelines once and for all.
So whether you’re a casual fan trying to make sense of it all or a horror buff who’s seen every timeline reset, this episode carves through the chaos with humor, & nostalgia.
____________________________________
2. Minisode: So You Want To Start A Podcast?
Host Michael Reagan thought it was the perfect time to turn the mic toward our listeners who might be thinking of starting a podcast themselves. After two seasons, 40 episodes, and plenty of lessons learned the hard way, Michael is sharing everything he has picked up along his own podcast journey—the good, the bad, and the “did that file really just delete itself?” moments.
____________________________________
3. S02E10: The 90s Scandal Sheet - First Edition
Welcome to The 90s Scandal sheet; a new segment from The 90s Rewind Report podcast. From jaw-dropping tabloid headlines to tragic news stories that stopped the nation, the 1990s delivered more than its fair share of scandals. In this episode of The 90s Rewind Report, hosts Michael Reagan, and Nate Lane revisit some of the decade’s most infamous and unforgettable moments — from the shocking Heaven’s Gate cult tragedy, the Monica Lewinsky and President Bill Clinton scandal, Paul Reubens’ public fall from grace, the Columbine High School massacre, the icy feud between Tonya Harding and Nancy Kerrigan and much, much more.
Equal parts pop culture time capsule and hard look back at the headlines that shaped the era, this episode doesn’t shy away from the messy, complicated truths behind the stories.
____________________________________
4. S02E20: David Sidoni - Roundhouse to Real Estate
David Sidoni is a performer and storyteller who helped define a generation of 90s pop culture. Audiences first met him in Disney’s Newsies, then every Saturday night on Nickelodeon’s Roundhouse during the original SNICK era. He also appeared as a dancer in Michael Jackson’s landmark “Black or White” music video, adding another iconic credit to a uniquely 90s resume.
Today, David is in what he calls the “third act” of his life. He’s a successful realtor and the host of the hit podcast How To Buy A Home, where he guides first-time homebuyers through the real estate process with honesty, clarity, and real-world insight.
In this episode, David joins hosts Michael Reagan and Nate Lane to revisit the golden age of Nickelodeon, reflect on the legacy of Roundhouse and Newsies, share stories from his time working with the King of Pop, and look back at the era that shaped a generation.
____________________________________
5. S02E07: Buffering...The 90s Online
In this digital deep dive, Michael and Nate explore the pixelated past of the internet’s earliest days in Buffering... The '90s Online. From the screech of dial-up modems to AOL chat rooms and GeoCities fan pages, they revisit the weird, wonderful frontier that defined the early web. The hosts trace its roots from military experiments to the ‘90s boom that brought the internet into homes, classrooms, and cubicles alike. Along the way, they unpack how Hotmail, Ask Jeeves, and Napster shaped a generation raised on slow downloads and endless curiosity.
____________________________________
Host Picks:
1. S01E20: Jingle All The Way (1996) Rewatch
What was the holy grail of toys that you wanted that one Christmas growing up? Was it a ghostbuster fire station or Ninja turtles sewer playset? Or was it a Turboman action figure?
If it was the latter, you may have had a little competition with a former terminator and a postal worker vying for the same prize.
In today's episode the guys do a detailed rewatch of the 1996 Christmas comedy Jingle All The Way. The film Stars Arnold Schwarzenegger, Sinbad, Rita Wilson, Phil Hartman, & Jake Lloyd.
So grab some of Liz's sugar cookies... "Put the cookie down!" and reminisce!
____________________________________
2. S01E23: A Very 90s Podcast Christmas Special
In the Season 1 Finale, Nate, Michael, & Brayden are all together again to reminisce about their favorite 90s Christmas memories, they also play clips from listeners and friends who share their favorite Holiday traditions. The guys will also work their way from 1989-2000, evaluating the most sought after toy from each year.
So grab some hot cocoa, and take a moment this Holiday season to sit back, relax, and reminisce with us.