The 90s’ Rewind Report

Dust off your spellbooks and grab your stakes! This week on The 90s Rewind Report, hosts Michael Reagan and Nate Lane are back, and they are bringing a very special guest with them. Semi-regular contributor Stan (better known as @nostalgiaatnite on Instagram) joins the studio to talk about all things spooky, silly, and supernatural.
In this episode, the trio dives deep into the eerie side of 1990s television. Michael, Nate, and Stan each pick one iconic supernatural 90s sitcom to shine a spotlight on, breaking down the magic, the scares, and why these shows still hold a special place in our hearts today. If you spent your Friday nights wishing you had magical powers or supernatural roommates, this trip down memory lane is tailored just for you.
Whether you were a die-hard fan of Charmed, never missed an episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, or stayed up late watching Poltergeist: The Legacy, this episode was made just for you!
Did your absolute favorite supernatural sitcom get left out of the conversation? Don't panic! Part 2 is coming September 4th, and the guys are going to dive into as many as possible to make sure no spell is left uncast. Tune in, get nostalgic, and let us know which 90s supernatural show was your favorite!
 

🏚️ Two haunted houses. One year. One clear winner.
In this episode of The 90s Rewind Report, Michael Reagan and Nate Lane step inside two very different versions of 1999 horror: House on Haunted Hill and The Haunting. Both films brought big stars, big houses, and plenty of supernatural chaos to the big screen — but which remake actually delivered the better haunted-house experience?
Joining Michael and Nate once again is guest host Stan (@nostalgiaatnite on Instagram), returning to play devil’s advocate and serve as the potential tiebreaker if the guys find themselves completely gridlocked.
Spoiler alert: they didn't.
In fact, when the dust settled, there was a pretty clear winner among all three of them.
But which movie took the crown?
Was it House on Haunted Hill… or The Haunting?
Can you guess which one they picked? And more importantly… do you agree?
Press play, step inside the time machine, and prepare for a trip back to 1999 — because this haunted-house showdown is about to get interesting. 👻🏚️

Fire up the time machine and pack your Tupperware, because this week on The 90s Rewind Report, hosts Nate Lane & Michael Reagan are visiting the weirdest town in America: Eerie, Indiana!
In this ultimate retrospective, Nate & Michael unpack the premise of the short-lived, critically acclaimed 1991 sci-fi masterpiece. They deliver a comprehensive, episode-by-episode breakdown of the show’s entire limited run. No stone is left unturned as the duo dives deep into everything from everyday local oddities to the legendary "lost episode," which never made it to air during the original network broadcast.
The guys also shine a major spotlight on the incredible cast. They highlight a young Omri Katz tackling the weirdness of Marshall Teller long before he ever lit the Black Flame Candle as Max Dennison in Hocus Pocus. Plus, keep your eyes peeled for a look back at the show's staggering lineup of unknown young guest stars. Michael and Nate trace their early steps in Eerie before they grew up to become major household names.Whether you are revisiting the town or discovering its strange secrets for the first time, this is an investigation you won't want to miss!

We asked him to come back to our little corner of chaos—and for some reason, he agreed! If you just finished listening to S03E18: Top 5 underrated '90s Shows, then you are in for a treat.
This week, Michael Reagan is keeping the mics hot for an exclusive behind-the-scenes conversation with Instagram's own @nostalgiaatnite. This was the conversation that happened after we thought we were done recording. Now that the main debate is settled, we're diving deep into where the passion started that got him into collecting retro collectibles, and giving you the ultimate blueprint on how you can start your very own collection.Even though this booking was done organically, Stan and Michael also find a familial connection between him and cohost Nate Lane! Talk about a small 90s world after all!
Think of this as the VIP after-party for Episode 18. Grab your neon gear and let's keep the '90s chat going!

Grab your favorite slap bracelet and turn up the volume, because this week on The 90s Rewind Report, we are diving deep into the television archives!
Regular co-host Nate Lane is out this week, soaking up some well-deserved sun at the beach for a major birthday celebration. But the studio isn’t empty! Making his highly anticipated return to the microphone is the ultimate curator of memory lane, Stan—better known as the mastermind behind the massive Instagram community @nostalgiaatnite. If you loved his insights during our 4th of July I Know What You Did Last Summer double-feature special, you know you are in for a treat. As one of the internet's premier nostalgia collectors and pop-culture historians, Stan brings unmatched expertise to the table.This week, Michael Reagan and Stan are counting down their personal Top 5 Underrated 1990s TV Shows.
Some of these hidden gems might genuinely surprise you. You might even find yourself screaming at your listening device, ready to defend your weekly devotion to these lost treasures! But let's face it—just because a show lived rent-free in your head doesn’t mean it was a prime-time ratings juggernaut or received the network promotion it truly deserved back in the day.We are finally giving these cult classics the spotlight they always belonged in.
But wait, there’s more! Stick around after the main countdown wraps. We are teasing a fascinating, exclusive behind-the-scenes conversation dropping very soon. In it, Stan pulls back the curtain on how he built his incredible physical nostalgia archive, and he delivers a secret blueprint so you can start building your own ultimate collection today.
Which underrated masterpiece did we leave off? Hit play, dive into the debate, and let us know your picks!

Cut to 1998.
Hosts Michael Reagan, Nate Lane, and returning guest host Tyler Jones have all spent weeks saving their allowances to plan the ultimate 1990s sleepover. Each guy has hand-picked two of their absolute favorite movies, two junk-food snacks, two hyper-colored beverages, and one definitive video game to rule the night. And for dinner? It is a unanimous vote for pizza, obviously!
Unfortunately, when they hand over their neon, gel-penned invites, they realize disaster has struck: all three sleepovers are scheduled for the exact same Friday night. Now, the ultimate battle for your weekend attendance is on. Three distinct invitations are being slipped directly into your school locker...Grab your favorite sleeping bag, dust off your inflatable furniture, and tune in to find out which host throws the sleepover that no true nostalgian can turn down. Which party will you be RSVPing to?

Grab your flannel and get ready to cry orange soda tears!
Hosts; Nate Lane and Michael Reagan dive deep into the emotional, superheroic heart of Wellsville.
This week, the guys tackle the legendary two-part masterpiece "Farewell, My Little Viking" (originally aired on SNICK: November 13 and November 20, 1994).
Michael & Nate break down John McFlemp’s sinister International Adult Conspiracy and how it successfully targets Don Wrigley.
They discuss Papercut's tyrannical Paper-only playground regime,  & Little Pete's legendary scissor-throwing defiance.
The hosts analyze the heartbreaking moment Artie leaves town,  and Little Pete's ultimate solo showdown against Papercut.
It's a packed episode exploring inner strength, the end of childhood, and why Artie remains the ultimate personal superhero for every true 90s kid.
 

Grab your controllers and blow the dust out of your cartridges! This week on The 90s Rewind Report, hosts Michael Reagan and Nate Lane are plugging into the ultimate time machine to trace the massive evolution of the video gaming world.
The guys are tracking the journey all the way from the neon-lit floors of your favorite local arcades straight through the home console boom of 1999—and even saving room for a few crucial outliers that spilled into the new millennium. Mikey and Nate break down the heavy-hitting hardware of the decade, unpacking the official release dates and those unforgettable, wallet-draining launch prices that left our parents in absolute shock.
From the defining masterpieces to the absolute pixelated disasters, no game is safe. Plus, they dive deep into one of the wildest phenomenons of the 16-bit era: how identical titles released on both the Sega Genesis and Super Nintendo could end up having completely different storylines, graphics, and gameplay mechanics.
You don’t have to insert a quarter to listen, if you want in on this ultimate trip down memory lane, you’ve only got to ::PRESS START::

Happy Fourth of July, Nostalgians! 🎆 For our big holiday special, we are heading straight down to the Southport docks for a local beauty pageant, holiday fireworks, and a terrifying visit from everyone's favorite hook-wielding fisherman! ⚓️🪝
 
This week, Michael and Nate are diving deep into the ultimate 90s teen slasher double-feature: I Know What You Did Last Summer (1997) and I Still Know What You Did Last Summer (1998). We break down the iconic casts, track the brutal timelines of the fisherman’s revenge, and revisit the legendary fan-favorite moments that still make us scream (including Helen's tragic alley run and Julie's infamous roadside meltdown).
Plus, we tackle the ultimate 90s education crisis: how a failed geography question about the capital of Brazil trapped an entire generation of moviegoers. 
Stepping into the time machine with hosts Michael Reagan, and Nate Lane on this retrospective is special guest Stan (aka @nostalgiaatnite from Instagram)! We chat about the incredible retro community he has built and get his expert take on why these two films remain the ultimate summer horror staples.Have a safe holiday weekend! 
 

What was it like to be at the absolute epicenter of the 90s global dance explosion? In Season 3 Episode 13, Michael Reagan sits down with Eurodance royalty Tania Evans (the voice behind Culture Beat’s monumental smash 'Mr. Vain') and Kelly Overett (the powerhouse performer who dominated charts with SL2 and Cappella).
Both women look back at the sheer surrealism of flying across the globe, turning on hotel TVs in foreign countries, and seeing their own faces staring back.. From packing out international arenas, to unpacking the ultimate highs of 90s superstar status.Tania and Kelly also expose the high-stakes reality of navigating the music industry during the 1990s—diving deep into label politics, the fight to retain song rights, and the harsh shock of transitioning from gritty underground raves into the commercial mainstream spotlight. They get incredibly raw about the psychological toll of surviving global fame during the era.
Today, they are channeling that incredible legacy into the global Originals Live Tour! You can catch them bringing these timeless anthems to international stages throughout 2026, with massive upcoming stops including:
Santiago, Chile (August 15)
Sofia, Bulgaria (September 17)
Cali, Antioquia, & Bogotá, Colombia (October 30 – November 1)
Winter Pride, Gran Canaria (November 5)
Lock in your spot to see them perform live by grabbing tickets at: originalslive.co.uk